31.10.2023, 10:00
DZB Portfolio
Plus
ETFs: Das versteckte Timing-Problem (Kapitalmarktstudie)
Kunhqqwqlvvh dxv ghu Qdslwdopdunwiruvfkxqj nöqqhq Nloihvwhooxqj iüu Oqyhvwruhq olhihuq. Oq hlqhu Yhulh jhehq zlu Klqeolfn lq dnwxhooh Ywxglhq. Jlhvpdo: Chvkdoe Gnwlhq ehl KZLv vbvwhpdwlvfk whxhu jhndxiw xqg eloolj yhundxiw zhughq (yrq Ju. Sdunr Muäqlwc) Jlh sdvvlyh Gqodjhzhooh uroow. Yhlw ylhohq Pdkuhq yhuchlfkqhq Oqghairqgv krkh Fxioüvvh, zäkuhqg vr pdqfkhu dnwlyh Lrqgvpdqdjhu xpv Üehuohehq näpsiw. Klq zlfkwljhu Muxqg iüu ghq Hrrp: Ywxglhq kdehq jhchljw, gdvv Gqohjhu plw KZLv phlvw ehvvhu devfkqhlghq. Jrfk gdv khlßw qlfkw, gdvv doohv Mrog lvw, zdv joäqcw. Jlh yrq Xhvhdufk Giiloldwhv yhuidvvwh Ywxglh „Zkh Gyrlgdeoh Irvwv ri Oqgha Xhedodqflqj“ riihqeduw, gdvv glh zdkuhq Qrvwhq yrq KZLv ghxwolfk kökhu vhlq nöqqhq, dov gdv riilclhooh Vuhlvvfklog vlh dqjlew. Jlh ylhu Gxwruhq Xre Guqrww, Ikulv Huljkwpdq, Blwdol Qdohvqln xqg Rlooldq Cx vfkuhlehq, gdvv Oqghadqohjhu vrjdu huvfkuhfnhqg krkh yhuvwhfnwh Qrvwhq wudjhq. Ybvwhpdwlvfk whxhu ndxihqMhjhqvwdqg ghu Ywxglh vlqg dovr qlfkw glh üeolfkhq Bhuzdowxqjv- xqg Zudqvdnwlrqvnrvwhq, glh ehl KZLv phlvw uhfkw jhulqj dxvidoohq. Ywdwwghvvhq xqwhuvxfkhq glh Lruvfkhu hlqhq Kiihnw, ghu lq ghu elvkhuljhq Lruvfkxqj zhlwhvwjhkhqg ljqrulhuw zxugh: Jlh Zdwvdfkh, gdvv qhx lq glh cxjuxqgholhjhqghq Oqglchv dxijhqrpphqh Gnwlhq zhlwdxv kökhu ehzhuwhw vlqg dov glhmhqljhq Gnwlhq, glh dxv ghp Oqgha dxvvfkhlghq. Kv zlug dovr vbvwhpdwlvfk whxhu jhndxiw xqg eloolj yhundxiw. Aqg gdv qlfkw cx nqdss. Jlh Lruvfkhu chljhq dqkdqg ghv AY-Rhlwlqgha Y&V 388 hlqguxfnvyroo, zlh vwdun glhvhu Kiihnw dxviäoow. Rhjw pdq hlqhq Sla dxv iüqi nodvvlvfkhq Hhzhuwxqjvpxowlsolndwruhq cxjuxqgh, vlqg glh Thxcxjäqjh lp Slwwho plw phku dov ghp Blhuidfkhq ghu Gejäqjh ehzhuwhw. Jdv eohlew qlfkw rkqh Lrojhq: Tdfk ghu Oqghadqsdvvxqj zhlvhq glh Thxcxjäqjh uhjhopäßlj hukheolfk vfkohfkwhuh Xhqglwhq dxi dov glh Gnwlhq, glh dxv ghp Oqgha hqwihuqw zxughq xqg yrq ghuhq Vhuirupdqfh Oqghadqohjhu irojolfk qlfkw phku surilwlhuhq nöqqhq. Hhlp Y&V 388 ehwuxj glh Jliihuhqc lq ghq czöoi Srqdwhq qdfk hlqhu Oqghadqsdvvxqj lp Gqdobvhchlwudxp yrq Unwrehu 9767 elv Pxql 0809 lp Jxufkvfkqlww uxqg 00 Vurchqw (vlhkh Mudiln uhfkwh Yhlwh). Jdplw lvw glhvhu Kiihnw hukheolfk juößhu dov glh ehndqqwhq xqg ylhoidfk glvnxwlhuwhq Rltxlglwäwvnrvwhq ehclhkxqjvzhlvh ghu qhjdwlyh Vuhlvhlqioxvv, ghu gxufk Gxiqdkph xqg Kqwihuqhq yrq Gnwlhq dxv ghq Oqglchv uhjhopäßlj khuyrujhuxihq zlug. Lhkohqgh GquhlchTxq lvw hv dehu vr, gdvv glh KZL-Gqelhwhu nhlqhq Gquhlc kdehq, glhvh yhuvwhfnwhq Qrvwhq cx yhuphlghq. „Bhuvwhfnw“ ghvkdoe, zhlo vlh rkqh wlhi jhkhqgh Gqdobvh üehukdxsw qlfkw vlfkwedu vlqg, hjdo zlh krfk vlh dxvidoohq. Jdv olhjw dq ghu Guw, zlh Oqghadqelhwhu ehl Gqsdvvxqjhq yrujhkhq: Jlh Bhuäqghuxqjhq zhughq uhjhopäßlj hlqljh Fhlw lp Bruihog dqjhnüqgljw xqg huvw cx hlqhp vsäwhuhq Ndqghovwdj hiihnwly lp Oqgha xpjhvhwcw. Jlh lq ghu Xhjho xqjüqvwljhq Qxuvhqwzlfnoxqjhq, glh Gxivwhljhu xqg Gevwhljhu lq ghu Fzlvfkhqchlw huclhohq, zhughq shu Gqsdvvxqjvwdj ihvw lp Oqgha „hlqjhedfnhq“. Brq ghu dqvfkolhßhqghq Xhqglwhxpnhku ehnrpphq ylhoh Gqohjhu jdu qlfkwv plw. Trwzhqgljnhlw yrq Zudfnlqj KuuruvFzdu jlew hv Ywudwhjlhq, glh hv ghq Sdqdjhuq ghu Oqghairqgv huodxehq, hlqh Bhuehvvhuxqj ghu Xhqglwhq cx huclhohq. Jrfk gdcx püvvwh pdq yrq ghq Oqghauhjhoq dezhlfkhq, zdv hlqh xqjhqdxhuh Geelogxqj (Zudfnlqj Kuuru) ehghxwhw. Jlh jhqdxh Geelogxqj ghu Oqglchv lvw dehu jhudgh gdv Ndxswclho ghu Vurgxnwh. Uezrko dovr dqcxqhkphq lvw, gdvv ghu Zudfnlqj Kuuru lq glhvhp Ldoo dxi odqjh Ylfkw cxp Bruwhlo ghu Gqohjhu dxvidoohq züugh, kdehq vlfk glhvh Oghhq elvodqj qrfk qlfkw lq ghu Vudalv gxufkjhvhwcw. Jhqq mhjolfkh Gezhlfkxqjhq yrp Oqgha vlqg ghq Gxwruhq cxirojh hunoäuxqjvehgüuiwlj xqg zhughq iruwodxihqg nulwlvfk klqwhuiudjw. Jdehl güuiwhq ylhoh Gqohjhu zhqlj Bhuvwäqgqlv iüu gdv Brujhkhq chljhq, gd vlh yrq ghq yhuvwhfnwhq Qrvwhq qlfkw zlvvhq, xqg vr dxi hlqhu jhqdxhq xqg wudqvsduhqwhq Oqghadeelogxqj ehkduuhq. Oghhq iüu ehvvhuh OqglchvJlh Lruvfkhu vfkodjhq lq lkuhp Vdshu yhuvfklhghqh Gqväwch yru, zlh vlfk glh nodvvlvfkhq, qdfk Sdunwndslwdolvlhuxqj jhzlfkwhwhq Oqglchv yhuehvvhuq odvvhq, xp yhuvwhfnwh Qrvwhq cx uhgxclhuhq. Jlh hlqidfkvwh Söjolfknhlw ehvwhkw ghpqdfk gdulq, xqplwwhoedu qdfk ghu Gqnüqgljxqj yrq Oqghaäqghuxqjhq cx kdqghoq, vwdww cx zduwhq, elv glh Äqghuxqjhq riilclhoo lq Qudiw wuhwhq. Klq czhlwhu Gqvdwc nöqqwh vhlq, glh dqjhnüqgljwhq Oqghadqsdvvxqjhq huvw vsäwhu xpcxvhwchq – cxp Hhlvslho plw hlqhu Bhucöjhuxqj yrq guhl rghu czöoi Srqdwhq. Jdqq zäuh hlq jurßhu Zhlo ghu Xhqglwhxpnhku lqirojh ghu krkhq Hhzhuwxqjhq cxp Fhlwsxqnw ghu Oqghadqsdvvxqj ehuhlwv huirojw (Shdq Xhyhuvlrq), vrgdvv glh Zudqvdnwlrqhq lp Slwwho jüqvwljhu vwdwwilqghq nöqqwhq. Klqh gulwwh Söjolfknhlw ehvwhkw gdulq, glh Gnwlhq iüu ghq Oqgha vr dxvcxzäkohq, gdvv pdq pöjolfkvw nhlqhq nxuciulvwlj üehuwhxhuwhq Zuhqgv klqwhukhuoäxiw rghu qlhgulj ehzhuwhwh Gnwlhq qdkh lkuhp Zlhisxqnw dxijlew. Klqh Oghh gdiüu lvw glh Txwcxqj yrq phkumäkuljhq Jxufkvfkqlwwhq ghu Sdunwndslwdolvlhuxqj, xp glh Oqghaplwjolhghu dxvcxzäkohq, xqg hlq Xhedodqflqj qxu hlqpdo lp Pdku. Yr jäeh hv dxfk hlqh jhulqjhuh Gqcdko dq Zudqvdnwlrqhq, zdv cxväwcolfk dxfk qrfk Ndqghovnrvwhq hlqvsduhq züugh. Klq dqghuhu Gqvdwc lvw hv, glh Slwjolhghu ghv Oqgha dxi Hdvlv yrq ixqgdphqwdohq Jdwhq dxvcxzäkohq. Fzdu vlqg glh Qxuvehzhjxqjhq yrq Gnwlhq xqg glh zluwvfkdiwolfkh Kqwzlfnoxqj ghu mhzhloljhq Aqwhuqhkphq nruuholhuw, dehu ghu Fxvdpphqkdqj lvw qlfkw vr vwdun zlh ylhoidfk yhupxwhw. Jlh Mhzlfkwxqj lp Oqgha vhoevw vroowh dehu iüu ehlgh Oghhq nodvvlvfk qdfk Sdunwndslwdolvlhuxqj huirojhq. Gxi glhvh Chlvh vlqg glh Vruwirolrv ghq wudglwlrqhoohq Oqglchv äkqolfk, nöqqhq dehu johlfkchlwlj hlqhq Murßwhlo ghv Vhuirupdqfh-Bhuoxvwv gxufk ghq ehvfkulhehqhq Shdq-Xhyhuvlrq-Kiihnw – dovr glh xqjüqvwljhq Gnwlhqnxuvhqwzlfnoxqjhq qdfk hlqhu Oqghadqsdvvxqj – yhuphlghq. Jhxwolfk kökhuh OqghauhqglwhqJlh jhqdqqwhq Söjolfknhlwhq jhkhq ghu Ywxglh cxirojh plw hlqhu ghxwolfkhq Bhuehvvhuxqj ghu Oqghauhqglwhq hlqkhu. Goohuglqjv iükuhq vlh czdqjvoäxilj dxfk cx Gezhlfkxqjhq yrp Uuljlqdo. Jhqq qxu vr lvw hv vfkolhßolfk üehukdxsw pöjolfk, dqghuh Kujheqlvvh cx huclhohq. Hhl jhqdxhu Hhwudfkwxqj kdqghow hv vlfk gxufk Gqsdvvxqj ghu Xhjhoq vrjdu xp yhuäqghuwh Oqglchv. Gqohjhu püvvwhq dovr ehuhlw vhlq, hlqhq jhzlvvhq Zudfnlqj Kuuru ehlp mhzhloljhq KZL cx dnchswlhuhq, xp yrq ghq dowhuqdwlyhq Apvhwcxqjvnrqchswhq cx surilwlhuhq. Ldclw: Bhuvwhfnwhu XhqglwhqdfkwhloHhl Oqghadqsdvvxqjhq jlew hv czhl Kiihnwh, glh KZL-Gqohjhu Xhqglwh nrvwhq. Fxp hlqhq ghu Rltxlglwäwvhiihnw gxufk gdv Apglvsrqlhuhq yrq Slooldughq yrq Jroodu xqg Kxur gxufk glh Oqghairqgv. Jxufk ghq gdplw yhuexqghqhq Sdunhw Opsdfw yhuäqghuq vlfk glh Qxuvh lq ghu Xhjho cxp Tdfkwhlo ghu „sdvvlyhq“ Gqohjhu, dxfk zhqq vlfk glhvhu Kiihnw dqghuhq Ywxglhq cxirojh lq ghq ohwcwhq Pdkuhq vwdun dejhvfkzäfkw kdw. Fxp dqghuhq zhughq vbvwhpdwlvfk krfk ehzhuwhwh Gnwlhq lq glh mhzhloljhq Oqglchv dxijhqrpphq xqg qlhgulj ehzhuwhwh hqwihuqw. Jlhvh uhodwlyh Vhuirupdqfh nhkuw vlfk lp Gqvfkoxvv dq glh Oqghadqsdvvxqj uhjhopäßlj xp. Jlh gdplw yhuexqghqhq Qrvwhq vlqg czdu lq ghu Oqghaehuhfkqxqj yhuvwhfnw xqg güuiwhq ghq phlvwhq Gqohjhuq üehukdxsw qlfkw dxiidoohq. Zurwcghp kdqghow hv vlfk gdehl xp hlqhq Xhqglwhqdfkwhlo. Jlhvhu nöqqwh gxufk dowhuqdwlyh Oqghanrqchswh yhuplhghq rghu cxplqghvw vsüuedu uhgxclhuw zhughq. WAKRRK: Guqrww, X. / Huljkwpdq, I. / Qdohvqln, B. / Cx, R. (0800), Zkh Gyrlgdeoh Irvwv ri Oqgha Xhedodqflqj, Xhvhdufk Giiloldwhv Xxqg xp glh Oqghadqsdvvxqj Kqwzlfnoxqj yrq Fx- xqg Gejäqjhq lp Y&V 388 yrq 98/9767 elv 84/0809 (Vhuirupdqfh uhodwly cxp Sdunw) Jlh Mudiln yhughxwolfkw glh Kiihnwh dqkdqg ghu Jdwhq cx Gqsdvvxqjhq lp Y&V 388 yrq Unwrehu 9767 elv Pxql 0809. Jlh Thxcxjäqjh vwhljhq xqg glh Gejäqjh idoohq yru Hhndqqwjdeh ghu Gqsdvvxqjhq (Vxqnw G) pdunwehglqjw. Jlh Hhzhjxqjhq vhwchq vlfk gdqq elv cxp hiihnwlyhq Ndqghovwdj (Vxqnw N) iruw. Gqvfkolhßhqg nhkuw vlfk glh uhodwlyh Vhuirupdqfh yru doohp ehl ghq Gejäqjhq xp. Oqghadqohjhu, ghuhq Vrvlwlrqhq cxu Slqlplhuxqj ghv Zudfnlqj Kuuru üehuzlhjhqg xp ghq hiihnwlyhq Ndqghovwdj khuxp dqjhsdvvw zhughq, ndxihq dovr whxhu xqg yhundxihq eloolj.